[REVIEW] Soundless – Richelle Mead

Richelle Mead
Soundless
Penguin (US, UK, CA: 10th November 2015; AU: 12th November 2015)
Buy (US Kindle Edition) Buy (US Hardcover) Buy (UK Kindle Edition) Buy (UK Paperback) Buy (CA Kindle Edition) Buy (CA Hardcover) Buy (Worldwide Hardcover) Buy (Worldwide Paperback)

NOTE: Throughout the book, the word is presented as “deaf”. In real life, I’ve also seen it as “Deaf” and “d/Deaf”. This review goes along with the novel, because that’s what I discuss.

Soundless is a standalone, and has a beautiful cover – the best art of any of the author’s books. It’s fewer than 300 pages, a quick read. Though I’ve seen mention of an embargo, Amazon Vine reviews were up before the novel’s publication, so the publisher gave a good push. The story involves Chinese folklore and deaf characters. Everything in this paragraph is a drawcard.

We begin at the top of a mountain, in a village full of people who’ve been deaf for generations, though ancestors were once hearing. Fei has been deaf all her life – until now.

It’s in the blurb (Australian edition), so it’s not a spoiler: Sound becomes her weapon.

And so one of the novel’s drawcards…withdraws. This is not a story with a heroine who’s deaf. This is a story with a heroine who’s originally deaf, but then mysteriously acquires full hearing overnight without any science or technology involved. She remains hearing without aids for the rest of the book.

So what does this mean? Would this story be possible if Fei had remained deaf forever? Hearing rocks fall saves her life, as does hearing other danger before it arrives. Had she not been able to hear, what would it have taken for Fei to investigate how to save her fellow villagers?

This isn’t as much of a story about a deaf person as it is about a hearing person.

Maybe I expected a feel-good story about a deaf person having adventures and saving the future. That could explain my somewhat disappointment that the novel’s about a hearing person having adventures and saving the future.

I look forward to reading marginalised people’s (deaf and/or Chinese) views on Soundless. Maybe I need further context to fully understand the novel, because as it is I’m kind of side-eying the story.

But even before I truly considered the book’s concept, my interest was fading. If you’re already skimming by Chapter 2, instead of properly reading, things aren’t great. It only really grabbed me from about page 200, so a case of too little too late. The scenery is breathtaking, and I’d love to learn more about the Chinese folklore that inspired Soundless. But I couldn’t stay focused and interested the entire time.

Advertisements

2 responses to “[REVIEW] Soundless – Richelle Mead

  1. I read the first five chapters on NetGalley and they didn’t wow me. It seemed predictable and I had concerns about the portrayal of deafness and hearing and Fei’s quick adjustment to hearing. I’m not surprised by your disappointment but I was hoping that your review would contradict my initial impression. I agree about the cover, lovely.

    • It’s a problem when the last third of a book is more interesting than the earlier parts – people may DNF. If Richelle Mead’s name wasn’t on the cover, I wouldn’t have been able to tell by the novel that she wrote it. It lacks her usual spark.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s